Health Insurance is complicated, but it shouldn't have to be. Often times turning 65, seniors realize that at that stage of their life, Health Insurance is redefined completely. What's worse, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) passed regulations that made calling seniors to discuss medicare illegal. Instead, starting at age 64.5 you get bumbarded by mail related to medicare, and it can be hard to decipher. Below gives some guidance on your options ahead, and if we can help you look at further, complete an intake here.
What do I need?
Enrolling in medicare is akin to taking a road trip. There is an order in place of designated stops along the way and once satisfying stop 1 and 2, you'll hit a fork in the road to determine your destination. There is no one way or right way to be covered. This guide will break that down and give you greater insight as you work through the medicare process to solve your medicare needs.
Stop 1: Part A
When
If you are 65 and eligible for social security due to your work history, you should turn on Part A starting the month of your 65th birthday: even if you continue to have work coverage. Why? As you will see below, most seniors don't have to pay for it and it will even coordinate with your employer benefits.
You can start the enrollment process as soon as 3 months prior to your birth month leading up to your 65th birthday.
In its simplest form, Part A covers approximately 80% of inpatient hospital claims.
For more specifics on what is and isn't covered, Medicare.gov has a more specific list of coverages here.
Also, Medicare.gov breaks down what potential copays and deductibles are associated with Part A here. These gaps are typically filled with a Medicare Supplement (see below) or replaced by a medicare advantage (see below) program.
$0 in premium for about 99 percent of medicare beneficiaries since they or their spouse have at least 40 quarters of Medicare-covered employement. Part A premium is taken out of your paycheck through FICA Taxes.
*If you don't have 40 quarters, see the cost breakdown below.
| Quarters Worked | Premium |
|---|---|
| Greater than 40 Quarters | $0 |
| Less than 40 and Greater than 30 Quarters | $252 |
| Less than 30 Quarters | $458 |
Social Security is the agency who processes Medicare enrollments. If you have turned on social security already, then you can either turn on Part A at ssa.gov, in person at a local office, or call the SSA Medicare Hotline at (800) 772-1213.
If you have not started social security income, the safest way to ensure you don't accidently opt into any other programs than part A would be to call the SSA Medicare Hotline and let them help you.
Stop 2: Part B
When
Unlike Part A, which we recommend turning on as soon as eligible, Part B has a few more layers to peel back. You are eligible to start the enrollment process for Part B up to 3 months before your 65th birthday, but timing is everything. If you are on employer benefits after age 65, you can delay enrolling in Part B and avoid a penalty as long as you have qualifying coverage.
Starting three months before you lose qualifying coverage, you should start the process of enrolling in Part B making the effective date the first of the month following your loss of coverage.
Similar to Part A, in its simplest form, Part B covers approximately 80% of outpatient claims. Like seeing the doctor, specialist visits, lab work, etcetera.
For more specifics on what is and isn't covered, Medicare.gov has a more specific list of coverages here.
Also, Medicare.gov breaks down what potential copays and deductibles are associated with Part A here. These gaps are typically filled with a Medicare Supplement (see below) or replaced by a medicare advantage (see below) program.
$170.10 monthly for most medicare beneficiaries. Unlike Part A which collects premium from your paycheck, Part B premium is collected throughout retirement. The amount of premium is based upon looking at your income from two years ago.
If your income typically exceeds $91,000 if you are not married or $182,000 if you are, then take a look at this Medicare.gov table here as the cost will be higher.
Since Part B has a cost, defer enrolling in Part B until you no longer have employer coverage. If your employer premiums exceed $270 per month, then it may make sense to weight both options with a broker.
Once you are three months out from losing employer coverage (through yourself or spouses retirement) then follow the Part A recommendations to contact the SSA Medicare Hotline at (800) 772-1213 and get enrolled in Part B.
Stop 3: The Fork
As mentioned above, Medicare Parts A and B cover roughly 80% of hospital and provider claims across the board. The striking concern comes when one realizes 80% of a $500,000 hospital stay still leaves you exposed to a $100,000 out of pocket bill. To fill in the gaps, insurers and the government came to the table with two different ways to fill in that gap. That's where this metaphorical fork comes in. The options are two fundamentally different ways to look at medicare, and leave you with the choice on what best suits your needs.Option 1: Medicare Supplement + Rx Drug Plan (Part D)
Traditionally people have made a "left" toward medicare supplement, founded in 1980 with COBRA, when they were more concerned about, and willing to pay a premium for comprehensive medical coverage and less focused about the ancillary benefits.
As mentioned, Medicare Parts A & B cover approximately 80% of the medical costs a senior might incur. A Medicare Supplement, sometimes referred to as Medigap, helps to fill in the nooks and crannies of what is not covered in traditional Medicare. There are a range of Medicare Supplement plans (not to be confused with Medicare Parts) that the government has standardized, but individual insurance companies offer.
The most common plans consumers are asking about are plan F (if you turned 65 prior to 1/1/2020) or plan G. In the case of the latter, it fills in all expenses not covered by Medicare Parts A and B except a Part B deductible which for 2021 is $233. Other plans (A - N) can be found here.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Predictable: A set monthly premium for Part B (typically 170.10) and a Plan G (typically between $100 - $150 per month, plus the one time annual Part B Deductible ($233) are the only out of pocket costs for medical expenses. |
A La Carte: In the event you want dental, vision, or fitness benefits, you may have to purchase them seperately.
Unlike Option 2: which tends to bundle in these, plus a drug plan (Medicare Part D), Option 1 requires you hold each insurance plan seperately. |
| Network: If your provider works with Medicare, they will accept your supplement. These plans are great for retirees who have a second property out of state or do alot of traveling. | Medically Underwritten:Three months prior to, the month of, and three months after you begin your Part B coverage (assuming you had qualifying coverage before your Part B coverage) you have free reign to select a Medicare Supplement plan that suits your needs. Beyond this window, however, these plans are medically underwritten. What this means, is if you pick an insurance company who has poor customer service, aggressive sales tactics or other unfavorable situations, switching after your initial window will only be available if you are still healthy. That's why getting it right at first requires a dive into not just the plan and premium, but the company too. |
| Set and Forget: Often people who go the route of medicare supplement do alot of research at the beginning of retirement on a plan and stick with it for the long haul. Unlike Medicare Advantage (option 2) which changes each year and has an open enrollment component, Medicare supplement is pretty stable. | Monthly Premium:With Option 2: Medicare Advantage (MA), there are several insurance plans at $0 per month. You still have Medicare Part A and Part B premiums (typically $170.10) with MA, but beyond that there are options with no premium. Comparitively, with Option 1: Medicare Supplement, you pay for the piece of mind and simplicity that accompanies Medigap. In addition, for each benefit you add (dental,vision,rx) you have an additional cost. In most cases Medicare supplement packages, including Medicare Part A, B, supplement Plan G and a Drug Plan (Part D) will begin around $270 per month per retiree. Sadly, for those subject to the Affordable Care Act, many see this as a steap discount to their prior plans. |
Rx Drug Plan (Part D)
If you are buying a supplement, you must get a stand alone drug plan. We look directly to Medicare.gov here. Plans start at roughly $10.00 and up and can be changed annually during the open enrollment period spanning from October 15th, through December 7th. The average cost, however is $32.74 accross the US and is used to assess a penalty to those who decide to opt out of drug coverage.
We recommend, for how low the base plan cost is, that when you do switch over to medicare to enroll in a drug plan right away. This is because if you don't there is a penalty for every month you do not have coverage and you pay that penalty for the rest of your life.
The reason? CMS recognized that people were going without drug coverage early in retirement and picking it up in later years. Some were caught without drug coverage when they needed it mid plan year, and others were shaving off years of coverage. To create a level playing field, say you skip the first 5 years of coverage, they will assess a penalty to recoup the 5 years of premium you would have paid. At $10+ per month, it's better to just have something in place for now.
If you do have underlying medical conditions, Medicare.gov allows you to put in your medications, doseages and your pharmacy to get actual out of pocket costs for the year. The link above is a great tool for comparing the all in costs of a plan, not just the plan premiums.
Traditionally people have made a "right" toward medicare advantage, founded in 1997, when they are more concerned about premiums, bundling coverage and don't have alot of medical conditions or do alot of traveling.
Unlike Option 1 where traditional Medicare (Parts A & B) covers 80% of medical expenses and a standalone Medicare Supplement (Plan G) fills in the nooks and crannies, CMS and Bill Clinton's administration realized in 1997 that with the baby boomer generation set to retire in droves, an 80% liability to the government was not sustainable.
Instead, the introduced Medicare Advantage (so named in 2003) as a solution where they would transfer all responsibility of medical claims to the insurance company through a Medicare Advantage Plan. You are still responsible for Part B premium, but the government reroutes that and on average $830 per member per month (source, pg 13) to the insurance company to have them cover your medical expenses. This is why many MA plans have no additional premium to the consumer. Premiums present themselves when ancillary benefit costs exceed the $830 allotted for the member.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| $0 Premium Options: With option 1 the monthly premium starts at $300 per month, whereas Medicare Advantage can actually be $0 premium. All in costs start at $170.10 for the Part B premium, but that's it. | Out of Pocket Costs (OOP): When you put 100% of the responsibility on the insurance company, you come out with a product that moreso resembles a plan like the under 65 population is used to. With Option 1 your expense is the monthly premium for Parts A, B, Plan G, and your Drug Plan. The only other expense are your drug copays and the Part B deductible. For Medicare Advantage there are copays for each procedure, copays to see the doctor, deductibles, and out of pocket limits that could max out of pocket of $6,700 for some MA plans. |
| Flexible Plan Changes: Unlike Medicare supplement which is fully underwritten after your initial period, MA allows you to change plans annually. What this means for health retirees is you can start with a $0 premium plan and each open enrollment period change to a different program should your health change. Anticipating additional dental work, or on a new medication? This flexibility allows you an annual opportunity to change plans to suit your needs. | Network: If you travel alot or have a second home in the sunshine state, these plans are heavily reliant on a medical network. Unlike Medicare where most providers work with it accross the united states, picking an MA plan is a matter of weighing the network of providers. Picking a local carrier will give you access to better negotiated prices, where picking a national carrier may give you better access to providers if out of state. Disclaimer: If you do move out of the area, this does open a Special Enrollment Period where you can switch to another plan mid year. Be mindful that this change would reset any deductible for the year. |
| Bundled: Where Option 1 is typically more A La Carte, Option 2 tends to bundle multiple benefits under one plan. Medicare Advantage plans are required to be at least as comprehensive as Medicare Parts A and B, but to incentivize people to enroll in their plans they often offer benefits like hearing aid stipends, dental, vision drug and fitness benefits under one bundled plan. For those concerned about ancillary benefits, MA can be a great option. |
Options: Consiquently with all of the moving parts (different premiums, deductibles, networks, plan types, ancillary benefits) people can get overwhelmed by MA. There is a reason that brokers have to get additional certifications annually by AHIP and each carrier they represent to keep current on all of the plan features.
What do our clients typically look for in Medicare Advantage Plans? Most clients like plans that are PPO's with a $0, or close to it, deductible, $0 premiums, reasonable copays, and a strong network. |
